Close _CaptionTechnology has come far in the last 5 to 10 years. With Deaf individuals, groups and allies advocating for Equal Communication Access, Deaf, hard of hearing and late-deafened people are more able to access television programs, news, movies and entertainment like our hearing peers. But there is still one area that falls way behind the times: Online Internet  Video Captioning.

For example: YouTube videos have CC buttons which give the viewer the option to choose a language that will caption the video using automated voice recognition software. The powers that be think this satisfies their legal obligation to provide “access” for us folks who require captions. But have you ever watched the captions as they appear using electronic voice recognition software?  Oh…. my…. word! They are ridiculous!!

I went to this video embedded below and turned on the CC button to transcribe it in English. It’s a lovely, short, Ocean Guided Visual Meditation with Deepak Chopra from the website Wild Divine. The description of the video says, “Guided meditation is an integral part of my daily ritual, and sometimes it’s a nice way to relax. This ocean guided meditation with Deepak Chopra is about natural beauty and finding your own inner beauty through mindfulness, and further it is about taking that with you into the world everyday.”

It also includes a nice quote from Chopra:

Joy is a return to the deep harmony of body, mind, and spirit that was yours at birth and that can be yours again. That openness to love that capacity for wholeness, with the world around you is still within you.  -Deepak Chopra

So I had an idea what to expect. However, after I watched it, relaxation was the last thing I was feeling! The first few sentences using this automated voice recognition software these companies think does the trick, came out like this:

Close your eyes
and
take a few slow depressants.
Repeat influent hotels repressed

allow yourself to become more relaxed
more comfortable, more peaceful

I was not relaxed, not comfortable and far from peaceful. Heck! I was pissed! THESE CAPTIONS ARE NOT OK! This is what we Deaf folks have to endure. Internet companies think they are abiding by the laws and providing Equal Communication Access by using the cheapest form of translation, using automated voice recognition software. But this kind of captioning is far from Equal. This is NOT Access. This is deep confusion. This is wrong!

Take a look at the video below. Turn on the CC button and translate to English. See what I mean. (For those of you who cannot open or access the video, I have provided the translation from the video in text below.)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=D56tUOdpgts

Close your eyes
and take a few slow depressents.
Repeat influent hotels repressed
allow yourself to become more relaxed
more comfortable, more peaceful
as you drift into a deep stated relaxation
tutor transported to appeal to food scene
natural environment
d_n_a_ school fragrant
with usual of sweet tropical shaw’s
disguised deep
with julia who had been doing tell
easily floating by
this firm dates units
comforting one night
the sounds of exotic bird song
and the rest of the soft breeze
through the trees
offers scooting
auditory packard
the churn his lunch
no extravagance in ontario
bash, abundant, extravagant
exotic centro
induced beautiful place
imagine yourself lying down a blanket
and the soft crusty man
feel the sens of connection
the sense of comfort
two hundred nature along
allowing the nutrients
or sensations or sights and smells
to keep the u_s_ himself deep conflict
you are returning creation
enjoyed this experience
of being increased in the church
by mother nature
this is where you came from
got
community
till you’re interested in fact disputes
in time
and carry your feelings of comforting
and relaxation wherever you call
they have a yahoo.com
brings a whole universe mature
and then you’re ready to open their eyes
dance of the screen to see holding
product the state of inability
back into your body
unharmed

Sigh…..

Comments welcome.

4 Responses to “Why Some Captions Are Not OK ~”

    Wow, that’s pretty bad captioning.

    I have an image in my mind of someone trying to meditate with these instructions. The tutor would probably be happy to be transported to appeal to food scene, since I assume that means going out to a restaurant (but not an extravagant restaurant — at least not in Ontario). But the soft crusty man would get squished.

    I hope this technology improves, but yeah, that’s really not OK.

    I have experienced the same frustration. I work as an interpreter in high school, and I am required to remind the teachers to turn on the CC for the student. Whenever we do on a YouTube video, it is so wrong it is distracting and becomes a joke for the whole class.

    I really enjoyed this article! YouTube video captioning should not even exist. To me, it’s sort of like false advertisement of services – which is illegal. In class (I am a college student), the professor was showing a youtube video. I shared with her that it was not captioned appropriately. I went to her office to try to demonstrate to her how horrible the captioning was. My professor was a wonderful person but, she couldn’t see what the problem was. I insisted that she turn the sound off, wait, and try to read it…. then, she was like “oh, my goodness, this is just awful!” It takes persistence and patience to educate others on this. Keep up the good work!

    I totally agree with Kelly that they should not even exist cos they are false advertising a service. So is illegal. So I don’t know how they get away with it.

    I don’t even bother turning them on, because they are s**t basically. Way off the mark they are. So if video does not have captions that work. I don’t bother watching. It is a joke. But not a joke for us that need them.

Something to say?



Video & Audio Comments are proudly powered by Riffly

Copyright 2006-2008 by LaRonda Zupp

poker table
fast ways to lose weight
buy uk viagra
buy viagra in england
dating buzz sa
order viagra uk
buy viagra pill
cheap free viagra
buy generic viagra
buy discount viagra online
buy viagra online cheapest
buy viagra online without prescription
free birthday ecards
buy viagra low cost
buy nolvadex
reno casino
buy discount soma
cheep generic viagra
zombie assault free games
discount viagra sale
cheap levitra online
buy free viagra on internet
cheap no prescription viagra
cheap pharmaceutical viagra
buy keyword viagra
cheapest viagra online
cheap cialis online
cheap generic 50 mg viagra
buy no online prescription viagra
buy viagra without prescription
cheapest viagra on the internet
tinkerbell wallpaper
discount viagra mastercard
buy viagra online australia
buy viagra in bangkok
cheap cialis viagra
buy cymbalta
buy cheap generic viagra
levitra online
tamiflu
order levitra
fox sports betting
order mexican viagra
buy cheap purchase uk viagra
free slot games
cheapest place to buy viagra
discount viagra pills
buy viagra online au
buy online prescription viagra without
buy cialis online viagra
buy viagra woman
cheap source viagra
cheap meltabs online viagra
buy discount levitra
cheap viagra nz
buy generic viagra viagra
buy viagra from brazil
hallmark ecards
buy cost low viagra
cialis online
cheaper viagra levitra cialis
buy viagra cheap
buy now viagra
buy online online pill viagra viagra
cheap viagra direct
buy viagra cheaply
cheap drug viagra
cheapest prescription viagra
order viagra
buy softtabs viagra
cheapest regalis viagra
cheap generic viagra online
buy viagra internet
buy viagra contact us page
oberon games
buy pill viagra
cheap pill viagra
totally crap
buy cheap cialis
order viagra viagra
advance cash ecard gsis
cheap deal pill viagra viagra
buy viagra and overseas
viagra by overnight delivery
buy real viagra pharmacy online
snowman wallpaper
buy viagra over the counter
buy real viagra online pharmacy
usa cialis
buy viagra online u
buy online pill viagra
cheap generic viagra no script
buy viagra on line
sandlot games
funny birthday sayings
cheap generic viagra substitutes
buy viagra line
tamiflu
order site viagra
cheapest cialis
cialis 2005
ideas for homemade games for teens
buy lexapro
buy australian viagra
sports athority
order viagra now money
teenie files
sports bloopers
buy norvasc
buy deal online sale viagra viagra
cialis 24
buy viagra cheapest
buy viagra online a href
buy viagra prescription america
cheap viagra bi
discount viagra pharmacy online
order viagra online uk
buy viagra without a prescription
buy viagra 100mg
buy viagra new york
order viagra now viagra money order
cheapest generic viagra and cialis
cheap generic viagra uk
discount viagra sale online
little creek casino
viagra brazil
cheap order prescription viagra
allegra
buy viagra for women
buy kamagra
buy viagra soft tabs
buy flomax
order viagra prescription
jbbs livedoor jp sports 12449
order viagra cheap
boris vallejo wallpaper
buy viagra cheap india pharmacy
buy canada viagra
discount levitra
buy viagra next day delivery
discount viagra brand drug
buy viagra viagra online
buy viagra us pharmacy low prices
cheapest price on viagra
buy viagra order viagra
buy sale viagra
cheaper viagra
cheap online viagra viagra
recover my files 2.29 key generator
order viagra air travel
buy viagra in amsterdam
funny tagalog qoutes
discount viagra
buy cheap site viagra
buy now cialis
cheapest generic viagra and canada
cheap viagra fast shipping
cheapest place buy viagra online
buy cheap online viagra
buy viagra online online pharmacy
buy viagra 1
buy cheap viagra on the net
buy viagra uk
buy free online sale viagra viagra
free hallmark ecards
buy overseas viagra
buy cheap generic viagra online
buy cheap viagra online now uk
viagra canada
buy viagra ups
cheap phizer viagra
buy site viagra
buy deal viagra
discount viagra perscription drug
buy viagra vaniqa prescription
order levitra online
viagra and cialis cheap
buy viagra onli
cheap deal discount price viagra
free bingo
buy discount cialis
baccarat strategy
buy viagra in london
discount viagra in the usa
order viagra overnight delivery
cheap viagra st
viagra buy it online now
buy viagra online canadapurchase cialis
buy viagra from an online pharmacy
buy viagra for cheap
azdg dating site
cheap mexico viagra
digimon adventure online games
buy cheap uk viagra
order discount viagra
buy cheap discount cialis
buy cheapest online place viagra
buy pharmaceutical viagra
buy real viagra
viagra buy ionline
cheap india viagra
cialis 10
buy avandia
telus web mail
turning stone casino
buy viagra in spain
viagra buy general
cheap viagra in the uk
cheap viagra credit
buy clomid
cheapest generic substitute viagra
cheap soft viagra
jailbait images
bingo cards
cheap soft tab viagra
discount viagra sales online
order viagra online a href
buy online purchase viagra
cheap viagra at online pharmacy
cheapest 4 quantity of viagra
order viagra on line
cialis no prescription
buy viagra in united kingdom
cheap viagra uk
buy coumadin
buy viagra online and get prescription
recover my files 2.28 crack
buy viagra in australia
cheap viagra 25mg
order viagra cialis levitra pharmacy
buy nexium
buy cheapest viagra
discount viagra online
how to play poker
buy online sale viagra viagra
dating corvallis oregon
wallpaper murals
buy viagra online in uk
viagra canada pharmacy
viagra cailis
yiff games
bclc keno
cheap viagra discount
order viagra without prescription
buy viagra cialis levitra
buy cheap viagra online u
buy prescription viagra
buy viagra pill online
viagra and cialis
buy viagra all information
buy deal online online viagra viagra
cheap online generic viagra
buy generic viagra online
cheap generic viagra
buy cialis canada
buy online viagra
cheap generic india viagra
ecards sensual
buy viagra online discount
buy viagra now online
buy say viagra
earthlink web mail
buy in uk viagra
cheap levitra online
buy pharmacy pill viagra
pontoon boat
mecca bingo
buy online order viagra
buy discount generic viagra
cheapest viagra uk
buy imitrex
icebreaker games for small groups
buy cheapest online viagra
order viagra without a prescription
buy cheap deal online viagra viagra
buy get online prescription viagra
buy viagra australia
motorbike games
viagra buy now pay later
viagra by money order
bigfish games
deck design
viagra brands
cheapest viagra online plus zenegra
buy viagra safeway pharmacy
cheap viagra online
buy viagra in the uk
cheap online sales viagra
cheap herbal viagra
cheap discount levitra online
order 50mg viagra
buy viagra london
cheep viagra
cheap deal discount viagra viagra
cheapest viagra online pharmacy
buy viagra free on internet
cheap canadian viagra
buy cheap viagra online uk
buy lopressor
discount viagra drug
cheap meltabs viagra
buy from pharmacy us viagra
buy cheap discount levitra
cheap viagra generic
buy viagra online web meds
cheap order site viagra
buy pfizer viagra
viagra by mail order
cheapest place to buy viagra online
order viagra here
cheap free viagra viagra
cheapest prices on generic viagra
buy levitra viagra
free majhong solitaire games
crap
buy viagra locally
buy deal deal price viagra
buy viagra online in australia
buy online drug viagra pharmacy
cheap cialis
funny icebreaker questions
bellsouth web mail
cheap kamagra viagra
friends reunited dating
cheapest viagra in the uk
cheapest generic viagra
viagra buy uk
buy viagra softtabs
buy viagra without prescription pharmacy online
cheapest price for generic viagra
cheap genaric viagra kamagra
cheap discount levitra
buy pill price price viagra
buy viagra and cilas usa
order viagra visit your doctor online
viagra buy online
dice games
buy form generic viagra
cheap viagra cialis india
buy viagra cheap prices
free printable baby shower games
discount viagra or cialis
buy cialis
cheap websites for viagra
buy prescription vaniqa viagra
viagra by phone
buy cheap viagra prescription online
buy cheap viagra
buy viagra bradenton
viagra and cialis and
viagra by the pill
viagra buy
cheap free price viagra
buy fosamax
buy lady uk viagra
buy levitra
buy levitra viagra online
viagra buy viagra
buy glucophage
order cialis and viagra
buy cheap deal viagra viagra viagra
buy cheap cialis generic levitra viagra
buy buying sale viagra
short funny rhyming poems
buy cheap tamiflu
buy viagra toronto
buy online sale viagra
cheap cheap viagra viagra
order order viagra
cheap viagra ambien generic cananda
order cheap viagra
buy viagra at safeway
buy nexium
buy caverta
viagra buy it
cheaper viagra levitra apcalis
buy cheap levitra
order uk viagra
cheap cialis online
cheap drugs viagra cialas
cheap pharmacy viagra
download bingo
buy levitra online viagra
cheap viagra cialis
buy viagra per pill
discount cialis
cialis without prescription
buy cialis online
cialis 20
viagra buying online
womens retreat icebreaker games
buy viagra without prescription online pharmacy
deck designs
order forms for buying viagra
cheap deal pill pill viagra
discount viagra canada
fargo decks
buy discount price sale viagra viagra
order viagra international ships
party poker